Open Everyday 11am till 9pm 1035 N Collier Blvd 239-970-0127
Image
Image
Image
Alt Text
Save 5$ on
45$ or more
Save 10$ on 85$ or more
Save 20$ on 150$ or more
Alt Text
10% off any 1/2 catering tray
20% off any full catering tray
Alt Text

Save $3.00 on any roll

Alt Text

Free dessert cake with any 2 rolls. 

Image
Save 5$ on 45$ or more
Save 10$ on 85$ or more
Save 20$ on 150$ or more
Image

Free dessert cake with any 2 rolls. 

Image

Save $3.00 on any roll

Image
10% off any 1/2 catering tray
20% off any full catering tray
mobile_coupon_header_4.jpg
Save 5$ on 45$ or more
Save 10$ on 85$ or more
Save 20$ on 150$ or more
Image

Save $3.00 on any roll

Image

Free dessert cake with any 2 rolls

Image
10% off any 1/2 catering tray
20% off any full catering tray

Choose from our made to order menu

Image

Classic Rolls

Fresh Lobster or Jumbo Crab21.99

Fresh Shrimp16.99

Served on a soft roll or lettuce wrap with a side of coleslaw and a pickle

The Connecticut

Served warm with melted butter

The Maine

With fresh mayo

The New England

Mayo, mixed greens & lemon

Image

Specialties

Bacon Maine lobster bites (5) 16.99

Served with a honey chipotle sauce

Lobster Mac & Cheese 21.99

Tempura Shrimp (5)12.99

Served with dipping sauce

Image

Specialty Rolls

Fresh Lobster or jumbo Crab23.99

Fresh Shrimp19.99

Served on a fresh roll or lettuce wrap with a side of coleslaw and a pickle

The Mediterranean

Mixed greens, tomato & truffle aioli

The LBI

Avocado, mayo & tomato

The Deep South

Chipotle mayo, jalapeno aioli & candied jalapenos

The BLT

Lettuce, tomato, bacon & bacon aioli

The Chesapeake Bay

Lobster and crab with old bay and mayo

The Hot Honey Chipotle

Lobster and bacon topped with chipotle mayo and honey

The Sea Pearl23.99
Lobster, Jumbo Crab & Shrimp. Served with melted butter, honey and old bay seasoning

For The Kids

Chicken Fingers 9.99

White Cheddar Mac & Cheese9.99

Chicken Sandwiches

Marco Island Chicken9.99

Toasted potato bread, chipotle mayo, mixed greens & avocado.

Crispy Chicken California9.99

Toasted potato bread, romaine lettuce, cherry tomato & mayo.

BBQ Chicken9.99

Toasted potato bread, sweet & tangy barbecue sauce, romaine lettuce & shredded Parmesan cheese.

Buffalo Chicken9.99

Toasted potato bread, delicious smooth Buffalo sauce with romaine lettuce and cherry tomato.

Soup & Sides

Fresh Soup 12oz 10.00

Lobster bisque, New England clam chowder

French Fries4.99

Add old bay rosemary & herb or truffle parmesan. +$1 each

Jalapeno Poppers8.99

Deserts

Key Lime Pie6.99

Chocolate Cake6.99

Image

Classic Rolls

Served on a soft roll or lettuce wrap with a side of coleslaw and a pickle

Fresh Lobster or Jumbo Crab21.99

Fresh Shrimp16.99

The Connecticut

Served warm with melted butter

The Maine

With fresh mayo

The New England

Mayo, mixed greens & lemon

Chicken Sandwiches

Marco Island Chicken9.99

Toasted potato bread, chipotle mayo, mixed greens & avocado.

Crispy Chicken California9.99

Toasted potato bread, romaine lettuce, cherry tomato & mayo.

BBQ Chicken9.99

Toasted potato bread, sweet & tangy barbecue sauce, romaine lettuce & shredded Parmesan cheese.

Buffalo Chicken9.99

Toasted potato bread, delicious smooth Buffalo sauce with romaine lettuce and cherry tomato.

Image

Specialties

Bacon Maine lobster bites (5) 16.99

Served with a honey chipotle sauce

Lobster Mac & Cheese 21.99

Tempura Shrimp (5)12.99

Served with dipping sauce

For The Kids

Chicken Fingers 9.99

White Cheddar Mac & Cheese9.99

Image

Specialty Rolls

Served on a soft roll or lettuce wrap with a side of coleslaw and a pickle

Fresh Lobster or Jumbo Crab23.99

Fresh Shrimp19.99

The Mediterranean

Mixed greens, tomato & truffle aioli

The LBI

Avocado, mayo & tomato

The Deep South

Chipotle mayo, jalapeno aioli & candied jalapenos

The BLT

Lettuce, tomato, bacon & bacon aioli

The Chesapeake Bay

Lobster and crab with old bay and mayo

The Hot Honey Chipotle

Lobster and bacon topped with chipotle mayo and honey

The Sea Pearl23.99

Lobster, Jumbo Crab & Shrimp. Served with melted butter, honey and old bay seasoning

Make it a Monster Mystic - Double the meat & bigger bun + $19

Want just a little more? Try the Mighty Mystic - 50% more meat + $10

Soup & Sides

Fresh Soup 12oz 10.00

Lobster bisque, New England clam

French Fries4.99

Add old bay rosemary & herb or truffle parmesan. +$1 each

Jalapeno Poppers8.99

Deserts

Key Lime Pie6.99

Chocolate Cake6.99

Image

Classic Rolls

Served on a soft roll or lettuce wrap with a side of coleslaw and a pickle

Fresh Lobster or Jumbo Crab21.99

Fresh Shrimp16.99

The Connecticut

Served warm with melted butter

The Maine

With fresh mayo

The New England

Mayo, mixed greens & lemon

Image

Specialty Rolls

Served on a soft roll or lettuce wrap with a side of coleslaw and a pickle

Fresh Lobster or Jumbo Crab23.99

Fresh Shrimp19.99

The Mediterranean

Mixed greens, tomato & truffle aioli

The LBI

Avocado, mayo & tomato

The Deep South

Chipotle mayo, jalapeno aioli & candied jalapenos

The BLT

Lettuce, tomato, bacon & bacon aioli

The Chesapeake Bay

Lobster and crab with old bay and mayo

The Hot Honey Chipotle

Lobster and bacon topped with chipotle mayo and honey

The Sea Pearl23.99

Lobster, Jumbo Crab & Shrimp. Melted butter, honey and old bay seasoning

Make it a Monster Mystic - Double the meat & bigger
bun + $19

Want just a little more? Try the Mighty Mystic - 50% more meat + $10

Chicken Sandwiches

Marco Island Chicken9.99

Toasted potato bread, chipotle mayo, mixed greens & avocado.

Crispy Chicken California9.99

Toasted potato bread, romaine lettuce, cherry tomato & mayo.

BBQ Chicken9.99

Toasted potato bread, sweet & tangy barbecue sauce, romaine lettuce & shredded Parmesan cheese.

Buffalo Chicken9.99

Toasted potato bread, delicious smooth Buffalo sauce with romaine lettuce and cherry tomato.

Image

Specialties

Bacon Maine lobster bites (5) 16.99

Served with a honey chipotle sauce

Lobster Mac & Cheese 21.99

Tempura Shrimp (5)12.99

Served with dipping sauce

Soup & Sides

Fresh Soup 12oz 10.00

Lobster bisque, New England clam chowder

French Fries4.99

Add old bay rosemary & herb or truffle parmesan. +$1 each

Jalapeno Poppers8.99

Deserts

Key Lime Pie6.99

Chocolate Cake6.99

For The Kids

Chicken Fingers 9.99

White Cheddar Mac & Cheese9.99

Make it a Monster Mystic - Double the meat & bigger bun + $19

Want just a little more? Try the Mighty Mystic - 50% more meat + $10

Make it a Monster Mystic - Double the meat & bigger bun + $19

Want just a little more? Try the Mighty Mystic - 50% more meat + $10

Let Us Cater Your Next Event

Image

Call us to discuss 239-970-0127

Small | $99.99 | Serves 4

  • 4 Rolls

  • Choice of Maine, Connecticut, New England

  • 16oz Cole Slaw

  • 16oz Lobster Bisque

  • Replace for Specialty Rolls +$10

  • Replace for Surf & Turf +$15.00

Large | $199.99 | Serves 8

  • 8 Rolls

  • Choice of Maine, Connecticut, New England

  • 1qt Cole Slaw

  • 1qt Lobster Bisque

  • Replace for Specialty Rolls +$20

  • Replace for Surf & Turf +$30
     

Mac & Cheese | Chicken Fingers

  • 1/2 Tray Lobster Mac & Cheese $69.99

  • Full Tray Lobster Mac & Cheese $139.99

  • 1/2 Tray Chicken Mac & Cheese $34.99

  • Full Tray Chicken Mac & Cheese $69.99

  • Half Tray White Cheddar Mac & Cheese $29.99

  • Full Tray Chicken Fingers $69.99

Soups

  • 1qt Lobster Bisque  $30.00

  • 1qt New England Clam Chowder  $30.00
     

Let Us Cater Your Next Event

Call us to discuss 239-970-0127

Image

Small | $99.99 | Serves 4

  • 4 Rolls

  • Choice of Maine, Connecticut, New England

  • 16oz Cole Slaw

  • 16oz Lobster Bisque

  • Replace for Specialty Rolls +$10

  • Replace for Surf & Turf +$15.00

Large | $199.99 | Serves 8

  • 8 Rolls

  • Choice of Maine, Connecticut, New England

  • 1qt Cole Slaw

  • 1qt Lobster Bisque

  • Replace for Specialty Rolls +$20

  • Replace for Surf & Turf +$30

Mac & Cheese | Chicken Fingers

  • 1/2 Tray Lobster Mac & Cheese $69.99

  • Full Tray Lobster Mac & Cheese $139.99

  • 1/2 Tray Chicken Mac & Cheese $34.99

  • Full Tray Chicken Mac & Cheese $69.99

  • Half Tray White Cheddar Mac & Cheese $29.99

  • Full Tray Chicken Fingers $69.99

Soups

  • 1qt Lobster Bisque  $30.00

  • 1qt NE Clam Chowder  $30.00
     

Join our E-Mail Club

Mystic Lobster Roll of Marco Island

1035 N Collier Blvd

Marco Island, FL 34145-2539

Call us at 239-970-0127

Open Everyday 11am till 9pm

Mystic Lobster Roll of Marco Island

1035 N Collier Blvd

Marco Island, FL 34145

Call us at 239-970-0127

Open Everyday 11am till 9pm

Mystic Lobster Roll of Marco Island

1035 N Collier Blvd

Marco Island, FL 34145-2539

Call us at 239-970-0127

Open Everyday 11am till 9pm